Well, that’s not a Redstart
I’ve been going back through some old bird photos with Nomen, and apparently I’ve been giving myself a little too much credit for my early identification skills.
This batch is from September 2014. Fall migration, close to home, and I was still pretty new to birding. I had ten photos keyworded American Redstart. Looking at them now, five are Redstarts and the other five are Philadelphia Vireos.
So, half right.
I don’t remember what happened. Maybe I selected the whole bunch and added the keyword without checking every photo. More likely, I thought I was photographing the same species the whole time. I’d like to blame the keywording, but I’m not sure I get to.
Either way, they sat in my catalog like that for twelve years. They had a name, and I had plenty of other photos to deal with, so I never went back.

Nomen picked up the mistake when I ran those photos through it. For this post, I went back and ran the whole folder again using version 0.15.0, with just the Birds group turned on.
Of those ten photos, it came back with four American Redstarts and five Philadelphia Vireos, all marked Clear match.
The remaining Redstart? It put the detection box around a clump of leaves instead of the bird. Not particularly helpful, but it did flag the result as Check this one. Looking at what was inside that box, fair enough. I couldn’t identify a Redstart from those leaves either.

That’s a useful result for me. It caught five wrong IDs, and the frame where it missed the bird was one it told me to look at.
I’d mostly been thinking about using Nomen to get through the photos I hadn’t identified yet. There are plenty of those. But this has me going back through folders I thought I’d already finished, too.
My birding has improved since 2014. The keywords I put on those photos haven’t. And unless I happen to open an image again and notice something’s off, there’s nothing reminding me that I might have got it wrong.
With more than 100,000 photos, I’m pretty sure these aren’t the only five.
If you want to try this on your own catalog, pick an older folder you think is done and run it through Nomen’s Quick Review. Compare what comes back with the names you already gave the photos. Start with Check this one, but have a look at the others as well. Clear match is still something you can disagree with, and Close call shows you the species that came close behind.
Untick anything you don’t want applied before writing the keywords. Nomen adds its names alongside your existing ones, so you’ll need to remove any incorrect old keywords yourself. In my case, adding Philadelphia Vireo doesn’t make American Redstart disappear.
All of this runs on your computer. The photos stay there, and the matching works without an internet connection.
Anyways, five vireos correctly named. Now to see what else I was confidently wrong about.